Every Greek island holiday reaches the evening where nobody can face another plate of grilled fish. Skiathos handles this better than most, with several genuinely good Italian kitchens rather than the usual tourist pizza.
Lo & La on the Old Port steps has been run by Lorenzo and Anastasia since 2005 and holds 4.5 across all three rating platforms — a level of agreement across 3,400+ reviews that indicates very few off-nights. Il Migliore is the pick for pizza specifically. La Cucina di Maria has the best courtyard and the island's most reliable gluten-free offer.
Maria's Pizza opposite the Town Hall is the long-established option; note that bread is served automatically and charged for, which catches people out.
